← All posts
Salons and med spas

Square Appointments vs Vagaro: cost and no-show fees

2026-11-21 · 9 min read

Rather not build it yourself? We build the automation on your tools and keep it running. Get it built for me→

It's Tuesday at a three-chair salon. Your 2:00 didn't show, the second no-show this week, and the paper book has no way to charge her for it. Two stylists you trust use two different tools. One swears by Square because she already takes cards on it. The other says Vagaro sends her new clients. You have both pricing pages open and they don't line up, because one charges by plan and the other by how many people take appointments.

This post puts Square Appointments vs Vagaro side by side for that salon. I read Square's Appointments pricing page, Square's general pricing page and Vagaro's pricing page on November 21, 2026. Every price below comes from those pages. Where a page doesn't say something, I say so and leave the gap alone.

Square Appointments vs Vagaro at a glance

Square Appointments Vagaro
Monthly price Free at $0, Plus at $49, Premium at $149, each per location. Pro is custom pricing $23.99 a month, labeled "Exclusive rate for the first 6 months," shown next to $30.00
How the price grows By plan and by location. "There is no employee limit" on calendars By bookable calendars. The page has a selector from "Just Me" to "7+"
Appointment reminders Listed on Free "Unlimited notifications & appointment reminders" in the base plan
No-show fees "Cancellation policy and no-show fees" is listed under Plus Not mentioned. The $10 a month Online Shopping Cart add-on covers "automatic credit card capture or deposits"
Waitlist Listed under Plus In the base plan
Rooms, chairs and equipment Resource management is listed under Premium "Calendar & resource management" in the base plan
Client forms Automatic contracts when a client books Forms add-on, $10 a month
Card rates Published per plan (table below) Not on the pricing page
Marketplace listing Not on the page Free listing. "We take $0 from your online booking"
Free trial 30 days on Plus and Premium 30 days, without email marketing, text marketing or the branded app

Square's bill is the easier one to predict, because the fee is flat per location and the card rates are printed. Vagaro puts more in the base plan (the waitlist, resource scheduling, a marketplace listing), but you only find out the real total once you set the staff selector and add up the add-ons.

What each one costs a three-chair salon

Square's monthly fee doesn't change with headcount, so a salon with three stylists pays the same as a solo chair.

Square setup Plan Monthly fee
Booking and reminders only Free $0
No-show fees and a waitlist Plus $49
Treatment rooms or shared equipment to schedule Premium $149
Second location on Plus Plus x 2 $98

Vagaro's page gives one number, $23.99 a month for the first six months, beside $30.00. The selector under it runs from one calendar to seven or more, and the FAQ says a bookable calendar is for "an individual who is performing services," which leaves out the front desk. The page text I read didn't print what each added calendar costs. So I can't give you a three-stylist Vagaro total from the page, and I won't borrow one from a review site. Set the selector to your real headcount and write down what it shows, then ask what that figure becomes in month seven.

Then add the extras you'd turn on. These are the add-on prices Vagaro lists:

Vagaro add-on Price on the page
Forms $10/mo
Online Shopping Cart (card capture and deposits) $10/mo
Check-In App $10/mo
Text Marketing Starting at $20/mo
Email Marketing Free to start, 1,000 emails a month in the base plan
Vagaro MySite website builder $20/mo
QuickBooks integration $10/mo
Payroll $34/mo plus $5 per employee
Branded App $100/mo

A salon that wants intake forms and cards captured at booking is adding $20 a month to whatever the selector shows. I went through each side on its own in Square Appointments pricing and Vagaro pricing.

Where no-show protection sits

If no-shows are why you're shopping, start with this row of the table.

Square lists it by name. "Cancellation policy and no-show fees" appears in the Plus feature list, and Plus is $49 a month per location. The page also describes prepayments ("Require your clients to pay in advance for specific services or as part of your cancellation policy") and deposits ("Collect a partial deposit when appointments are scheduled"), though the part I could read didn't say which plan each one starts on.

Vagaro's pricing page never uses the words no-show fee. The closest thing is the Online Shopping Cart add-on at $10 a month, described as a way to "set up automatic credit card capture or deposits." That sounds like the same job, but before you count on it, ask Vagaro whether you can charge a card on file after a missed appointment and which add-on that takes.

Both tools can only charge what your policy says, and the client has to have seen that policy first. If you don't have one written down, start with my no-show policy templates. Whether to take a deposit or hold a card is its own decision, and I laid it out in booking deposit vs card on file.

Card processing: one page prints rates, one doesn't

Square publishes its rates by plan:

Payment type Free Plus Premium
Tap, dip or swipe 2.6% + 15¢ 2.5% + 15¢ 2.4% + 15¢
Online 3.3% + 30¢ 2.9% + 30¢ 2.9% + 30¢

Square also says businesses processing over $250,000 a year can ask about custom pricing and processing fees.

Vagaro's pricing page lists no processing rate. It offers a free card reader when you sign up for Vagaro Merchant Services, and the footnote says you must process with them for at least 12 months after activation or pay a $150 early cancellation fee. The subscription itself can be cancelled "at any time, for any reason," with no fee, per the FAQ.

At a salon where most clients pay by card, processing can cost more per month than the software. Get Vagaro's rate in writing and run last month's card sales through both before you compare anything else.

Questions to ask before you move your book

Copy this list and take it to the sales chat or the trial:

  1. What is my monthly price with every person who takes appointments counted?
  2. What does that price become after any intro period ends?
  3. Which plan or add-on lets me charge a card on file for a no-show?
  4. What are the card rates for in person, online, and card on file?
  5. Is there a contract or early termination fee on the subscription, the card processing, or the reader?
  6. Are reminder texts unlimited, and do they count against any marketing text allowance?
  7. Can I import my client list, future appointments, and service history, and who does the import?
  8. Can clients book from Instagram, Facebook, and my Google listing?
  9. If I leave, how do I export my clients and their history?

How to choose

Pick Square Appointments if you already take payments on Square, you want a bill that doesn't change when you hire, and no-show fees are the main thing you need. Plus at $49 covers that for one location.

Pick Vagaro if you want a marketplace listing that can bring in new clients, or if you'd use the waitlist and resource scheduling on day one. Those sit in Vagaro's base plan and at Plus and Premium on Square. Go in knowing the add-on list and with the processing rate in writing.

If Vagaro is already on your shortlist against another tool, I compared it with a flat-priced competitor in Vagaro vs GlossGenius.

What neither one does for you

Both tools take care of the client who reaches your booking link. Clients who never get that far, or who leave without rebooking, are still yours to catch:

  • A new client calls while you're mid-color and gets voicemail. She books with whoever answers.
  • A regular walks out without rebooking and nobody notices for two months.
  • A late cancellation opens a 2:00 slot and the waitlist only helps if someone on it sees the message in time.
  • Nobody counts no-shows and rebooks by stylist, so you can't tell if the policy is working.

These can be handled with small pieces that sit beside either tool, using your own number and your booking link: a text back within a minute of a missed call, a rebooking nudge timed to the service, and a Friday summary on your phone. Builds start at $500 one-time, then a flat monthly from $99 after an included run-in period, cancellable. There's more on the salon and med spa automation page.

What stays with a person

Charging a no-show fee to a client of eight years is a judgment call, and you should make it before the card is charged. The same goes for a color correction consult, a nervous first-time client, or someone unhappy with last week's cut. Those need you or your front desk on the phone. I'd let the system send the texts and do the weekly count, and keep those calls with a person.

Before you pick one

If you're stuck between the two, or you're on one already and the phone still eats your afternoons, book a free 20 minute process audit. We'll look at where bookings slip in your week and whether the fix is a different tool, a plan change, or a small build next to what you have. Book it here.

08 / Start here

Tell us the task. We build it and keep it running.

Tell us what you use today and we'll reply within one business day with what it would take. $500 to build, 30 days of monitoring included, then $99/mo. Cancel the monthly anytime.

Email

pgorski@newfacedesign.com

Phone

+1 (773) 627-2176

Based in

Chicago area

Working with clients everywhere

Skip the form: grab a 20 minute slot.

Open the calendar →